Having just published the third book in my Justinia Wright, PI series and two short stories which take us back to a time before the series begins, I’ve had mysteries on my mind. And of late, I’ve been watching Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries.
I find the showed delightful. The characters are superbly drawn. They have history. They have issues. They are like real people. The mystery, on the other hand, is usually light and often flawed. On one episode, Miss Fisher gets an important clue by looking at a typewriter ribbon – a carbon typewriter ribbon. Oh, did I mention the era is the 1920s? Now that is what I call I gaping plot hole. But in spite of such faux pas, I thoroughly enjoy the show because the characters are so very lifelike. And the show is really about the characters.
For me the best stories are not plot-driven, but character-driven. I don’t give two hoots for the plot. In my mind, the plot is only there because the characters do something. Where’s the plot in Waiting For Godot? The story seems to get along quite nicely without one. Or how about The Remains Of The Day? The plot, such as it is, is merely the vehicle for us to listen to the ruminations of Stevens. Or what about The Moon Is A Harsh Mistress? Lots of plot there and yet the plot is merely the vehicle for Heinlein to present his picture of a libertarian utopia. In that sense, any plot could have worked. The plot in and of itself is non-essential. It’s the characters acting (giving us a plot) that is the real story.
Another example is Raw Head by Ben Willoughby. Willoughby creates two characters, has them do their thing, and the result is a strongly character driven story. Just as Ray Bradbury said it should be.
Christine by Stephen King, in my opinion, is a case of where the plot actually gets in the way of the story. And I think it was probably due to his having to write his book to a certain length for the publisher. But whatever the reason, two-thirds of the way through the book the story was told and yet King went on having the car create more and more senseless havoc, gore, and mayhem. For me, the extended and senseless plot ruined the book. Plot to my mind is highly overrated. Follow the Bradbury formula and your story will be told. After all, that is the real point of the plot. To tell a story. And your characters will do that for you.
So if the writers of Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries leave gaping plot holes, why bother watching? I think there are lots of reasons. Namely, the characters. Miss Fisher, a complex rich socialite with the past. Her companion, doc, who is in some ways miss fishers polar opposite. Inspector Jack Robinson, I somewhat stated police detective who gradually appreciates Mrs. Fisher’s talents. Constable Collins, who provides us with comic relief. And the list goes on.
Of course, this setting also contributes to the charm of the series: Melbourne in the 1920s. It is the perfect stage for larger than life liberated woman to walk apart.
There’s lots to like in Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries. Do give the show a try.
Share This!
I watched the first episodes of Miss Fisher last summer during my holidays… then the holidays finished and I couldn’t find the time to see the rest.
Which is a shame, because I love the show. I didn’t expet it to be this enjoyable, somehow I thought is was going to be kind of superficial. Not so!
Let’s see, maybe during Christmas holiday (apparetly I’ll have two weeks, but I’ll only believe it when I’ll see it) I’ll have the opportunity to see some more 🙂
It is indeed a fun show. I hope you get the chance to see more episodes.
I agree in that, if the story is good and the characters likable, then the plot (if any) is probably unnoticed. Some stories depend upon the plot to carry their characters. These are often readable, but also often forgettable.
Plotless stories are pointless and lack direction. At least, this is what some writers and critics will tell you. This is usually because the characters themselves are uninteresting. For me, the characters and the setting are more important than the plot.
Most plots are the same anyway. Look at Star Wars. Great characters, but a very average plot. Still, I absolutely love it because of the characters and the setting. One could write about a shopping trip to some far-flung galaxy aboard the Millennium Falcon and it would entertain immensely.
Btw, the Muse will accept cookies (homemade only), but only when served along with a glass of whisky 😉
Chocolate and red wine, or homemade cookies(made with butter, please) and whisky ;-), but I prefer to pair my sweets with a pint – chocolate and porter, cookies and IPA, lemon pie and Hefeweizen – Merry Holidays.
Chocolate and Porter – the perfect Christmas Carol! 🙂
After reading your post, I had to do some research on Bradbury and character driven plot. Interesting. So, I would infer, after my research, that watching Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries helps feed your mystery muse. I need to feed my muse more words and less holiday stress. 🙂
I think character-driven stories are more fun to read and write. And, yes, watching Miss Fisher has fed the Muse. 🙂 I have two more Justinia Wright short stories written, one for Christmas, which I’ll post this Sunday as a freebie. I think the Muse likes Christmas cookies, Alice. I really do. 🙂